Does one size fit all?
     
Loading

The Right Response #10

To Choose the Most Effective Policy you need a Choice
So the 10th Guarantees Each State can Choose Their Own...

Management science is clear, prescriptive solutions do not work. But why not? A solution imposed from outside stops you implementing your own unique strategy created and tailored to your particular situation. Since everyone and every circumstance is unique, how can one size ever fit everybody?

Business people competing in a race
Suppliers competing for your business give better results than monopolies. Anyone suggesting they know the one best solution for a country the size of a continent with a quarter of a billion people and the world's largest GDP makes absolutely no sense (often written as one single word: nonsense).

How can imposing one single federal policy allow for the best solution to become evident? When each state has the freedom to choose their own strategy, they get different results. Effectiveness become evident and, tailored to each one's individual circumstances, the best can be imitated.

The Value of Competition

Header Underline
Governments have some similarities to businesses, when a company has a monopoly, they try to get away with monopoly over-charging and lack of service. Without competition, there are no legal alternatives, so there's no way to measure customer satisfaction and find the strategy producing the most effective results.

Texas has been gaining both wealthy people along with their income from California because
people vote with their feet. With genuine competition, better results can be seen, and superior policies become obvious. The same is true for any issue - including reducing mass shootings!

The Tenth Amendment

Header Underline
Founding Fathers of the United States
The Founding Fathers were wise. They had the foresight to see that different policies followed in each of the Several States would allow comparison and highlight the best results. They understood that one size does NOT fit all, and had the wisdom to entrench competition in the Constitution.

That's why US citizens enjoy the protection of the Tenth Amendment. The Constitution was deliberately written with
very limited powers granted to the Federal Government. The 10th Amendment reads:

"The powers not delegated to the United States by the Constitution, nor prohibited by it to the States, are reserved to the States respectively,
or to the people."

As a review of the 10th Amendment shows very clearly, each state enjoys constitutional protection from federal interference in almost all areas, the commerce clause and its egregious expansion into private agriculture notwithstanding. And the 2nd Amendment reinforces the protection against any federal attempts to institute any controls on guns owned by citizens, see the previous article.

Which do you Choose? Eloquent? Handsome? Or Successful?

Header Underline
If you had a serious heart problem, how would you choose the surgeon for your operation? Do you choose the most handsome while ignore his substantial failure rate? The best one at convincing you that unsuccessful strategies and ideas actually work? Or, no matter how ugly or unprepossessing, would you choose the doctor proven to have the best success rate?

The most successful gun control policies will therefore be found by encouraging each state to choose and implement their own policies. This means the most successful federal policy is hands-off, to recognize the Founding Fathers' wisdom in the Tenth Amendment.

Aside. If you would like to improve your finances - or even become wealthy - then support candidates with proven wealth-creating experience in private business, those who have created their own wealth without relying on government largesse, handouts, pork, or favors. Don't support ivory-tower candidates or government employees, vote only for people who have become wealthy under their own steam.

Gun Control at the State Level?

Header Underline
Ilya Shapiro discussed gun control at the state level on NBC Nightly News:

"I'd welcome a different state trying to address their particular problems. Certainly Montana faces different issues than New York does. I don't think there's a one size fits all solution for the entire country."

Responsible states such as Arizona, Arkansas, Texas, and Wyoming are proposing to relax gun laws for responsible citizens. Yet others such as New York and California are implementing even more stringent controls.

This is excellent. Different policies by different states make their different effectiveness very visible. Devout believers in a unpopular strategy can vote with their feet and move to a state with policies in line with their conscience. After a while, the most successful policies to protect our children will become very obvious.

Didn't they Swear to Uphold the Constitution?

Header Underline
But I'm very confused. What do the words "I will ... preserve, protect, and defend the Constitution of the United States" mean? Haven't President Obama and members of Congress all taken the Constitutional oath?

So why the continual attempts to eliminate constitutional protection against a repressive Federal government? Why the ongoing efforts to increase Federal power and undermine the 10th Amendment? What about Senator Feinstein's shameful attempts to infringe your right to protect yourself in direct contradiction to the 2nd?

The 14th Amendment Specifies Loyalty to America

Header Underline
The Constitution of the United States
Section 3 of the 14th Amendment specifies loyalty to America and the Constitution. It disbars anyone who has sworn to support the Constitution and yet engages in rebellion against it. Which suggests that Senator Dianne Feinstein's gun control bill in direct conflict with the 2nd Amendment renders her unfit to hold office.

More knowledgeable minds interpret such actions as impeachable. One commentator volubly insists that you don't impeach US Senators, which is usually true. But shouldn't Senators be impeached when they violate their oath and seek to undermine the Constitution?

The fanaticism of the powerful ruling classes to ignore the constitution and institute federal gun-control mandates suggests there must be another reason. What do the oligarchy know that they are not sharing with the American people?

Perhaps they profoundly realize, as Lead Protection Agent and US Senate candidate Dan Bongino says:
There's no such thing as gun control, only people control.

** Your Next Step **

Life Strategies Header Underline
The Right Response cover
You want your family safe and protected from criminal assault. Learn how to persuade hardened criminals to fear for their safety and leave town. Enjoy the whole story here:
  • Dramatically improve your family's safety

  • Realize neither the police nor the government have any legal duty to protect you [say the US Court of Appeals!]

  • Convince your neighbors to take responsibility for their own protection

  • Slash the crime rate for your whole community
Protect you and your neighbors' vulnerable family, children and property with a Universal Gun Ownership Law. Find out how with this dynamic Special Report: The Right Response. Available for a limited period at a special introductory price. Get it today - right now - only $4.97!

The Right Response? How to reduce violent crime and guarantee your safety!

Food for Thought

Header Underline

"Politicians are masters of the art of deception."

- Martin L. Gross, brilliant social scientist, author of over a dozen books, including the bestseller: The Government Racket: Washington Waste from A to Z. His 1995 bestseller The Tax Racket exposed some of the frightening excesses of the IRS and called for its elimination.


The initial version of this article was published at ezinearticles:

http://ezinearticles.com/?Will-Dictating-One-Single-Policy-to-Each-State-Solve-the-Problem?-Part-10-in-The-Right-Response?&id=7624421

© Copyright worldwide Cris Baker, www.LifeStrategies.net. All rights reserved. Republishing welcomed under Creative Commons noncommercial no derivatives license preserving all links intact, so share this widely!
The Right Response cover
All our products are fully guaranteed, these time-tested secrets of success are delivered electronically - no waiting for delivery. Discover the truth about overcoming your self sabotage, stop reacting, find out why resistance doesn't work, and change your life.

     |       |      |    Facebook button